Sacramento roots. A more personal way home.
Homeownership and Real Estate

Zestimate is Broken and Zillow Knows It

Discover the truth about Zillow's Zestimate, how it differs from an appraisal, and why it led to the shutdown of their iBuyer division.

This article retains its original publication date. Rates, limits and program rules may have changed. Ask us to verify current options.

Original New Way Mortgage illustration for Zestimate is Broken and Zillow Knows It
Zillow’s Zestimate: What Went Wrong? 🏠

What is Zestimate?

Zillow’s Zestimate is a familiar name for many homeowners. It estimates a home’s worth based on various data. But is it always right?

Zestimate vs. Appraisal: What’s the Difference? 🤔

First, let’s clear this up. A Zestimate gives an instant estimate, using algorithms and public data. On the other hand, an appraisal involves a licensed professional inspecting a property firsthand. Appraisals are more detailed and, often, more accurate.

Get Preapproved Today

Why Did Zillow Shut Down Their iBuyer Division? 🛑

Zillow’s iBuyer venture relied heavily on Guesstimate 🤪 Unfortunately, there were cases where Zestimates were off, leading to losses. Because of this, Zillow had to shut down the iBuyer division.

When Zestimate Got It Wrong 😯

Although Zestimates can be close, they’re not foolproof. Missing renovations, recent market shifts, or unique home features can skew the numbers. These inaccuracies led Zillow into some financial tight spots.

Related: What happens when the Appraisal comes in LOW?

Why Does Accuracy Matter?

Imagine selling your home, only to find the online estimate was too high or too low. It could mean missed opportunities or financial loss.

So, Can You Trust Zestimate?

It’s a tool, and like any tool, it’s not perfect. While their Zestimation can give a good starting point, it shouldn’t replace professional advice.

Looking for More Home Valuation Info?

If you’re keen to know more about your home’s worth, talk or text at 916-570-6979 📱. Or drop an email at hello@newwaymortgage.com. For a face-to-face chat, set up an appointment at www.meetnewway.com. And don’t forget our YouTube channel! Get tips and tricks by subscribing at www.newwayhome.com 🎥.

The Power of Information

Knowledge is power, and knowing the difference between Zestimate and a proper appraisal is key. Stay informed, and always seek expert guidance when making big decisions about your property.

TURN READING INTO A NEXT STEP

Put this in context.

Related reading

Ask Aaron to review my options

Related resources are matched by topic, not personalized underwriting. Older articles retain their original dates; verify current program details.

Aaron Clowes, New Way Mortgage advisor
A REAL PERSON BEHIND THE PLAN

Aaron Clowes

Air Force veteran. More than two decades in mortgage lending. Clear explanations, practical comparisons and a conversation about what works for you.

NMLS #200900 · CA DRE #02103379
New Way Mortgage is powered by Xpert Home Lending, Inc. · NMLS #2179191 · Equal Housing Lender.

Read client reviews on Google ↗

What happens after you reach out?

  1. Aaron reviews your goals and the information you share.
  2. You confirm details and compare available paths, costs and tradeoffs.
  3. You decide whether to apply through the secure Xpert application.

An inquiry does not authorize a credit pull.

YOUR NEXT MOVE

Let’s make the numbers personal.

A calculator is a starting point. A conversation puts your options in context.