skip to Main Content

More Bad Advice from Dave Ramsey

Dave Ramsey Says Don’t Buy a House if You Won’t Live There for 5 Years – Is This Bad Advice?



Dave Ramsey, the renowned financial guru, has often emphasized the importance of financial stability and wise decisions. One of his well-known pieces of advice is not to buy a house if you don’t plan to live in it for at least five years. While Ramsey’s guidance is generally sound, there are instances where it might not align with your best interests, especially when you consider the average annual rate of home price appreciation, which stands at 5.37%. In this article, we’ll explore Ramsey’s perspective, challenge the 5-year rule, and provide insights into making informed decisions about homeownership.

Understanding Dave Ramsey’s Perspective

Dave Ramsey’s financial philosophy is built on the principles of budgeting, eliminating debt, and achieving financial independence. The 5-year rule he promotes suggests that individuals should only purchase a home if they intend to stay in it for at least five years. This advice stems from his desire to ensure that individuals don’t rush into homeownership and potentially put themselves in a financially precarious position.

Challenging the 5-Year Rule

While Dave Ramsey’s advice is generally sensible, it’s important to consider the rate of home price appreciation. The average annual rate of home price appreciation, currently at 5.37%, challenges the notion that you should only buy a home if you plan to stay for five years. This rate indicates that, on average, the value of your home could increase significantly over a shorter period.

Want to see more content about Dave’s bad real estate advice? 

Real-World Scenarios

Let’s delve into real-world scenarios to better understand this. Suppose you have a job opportunity in another city after just three years of homeownership. Ramsey’s advice might deter you from taking that opportunity, fearing financial instability. However, if the average annual home price appreciation rate of 5.37% continues, your home’s value may have appreciated considerably in those three years, allowing you to sell it for a profit, even after factoring in transaction costs.

It’s crucial to debunk the myths around home buying, recognizing that life often throws unexpected curveballs. Sometimes, you might need to adapt to changing circumstances, and homeownership shouldn’t be an inflexible anchor.

The Importance of Flexibility

Life is unpredictable, and circumstances can change rapidly. Being flexible and adaptable is often more valuable than sticking rigidly to predefined rules. Instead of fixating on a specific timeframe, assess your personal situation, including your career goals, family plans, and financial stability.

The Mortgage Company Perspective

At New Way Mortgage, we believe in providing individualized advice tailored to your unique circumstances. While Dave Ramsey’s principles offer valuable financial wisdom, we recognize that life isn’t one-size-fits-all. We encourage you to strike a balance between financial prudence and achieving your life goals.


Dave Ramsey’s advice to not buy a house if you won’t live there for five years has its merits, but it’s essential to view it as a guideline rather than a strict rule. The 5.37% annual average rate of home price appreciation challenges this rule, highlighting the potential for financial gains in a shorter time frame. Ultimately, your decision to buy a house should align with your personal circumstances and long-term goals.

If you have questions or need assistance with your mortgage decisions, feel free to reach out to us. We’re here to help you navigate the complexities of homeownership and make informed choices.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

  1. Is Dave Ramsey’s advice always applicable?
    • Dave Ramsey’s advice is a valuable guideline, but it’s not a one-size-fits-all solution. Your unique circumstances should dictate your decisions.
  2. What should I consider before buying a home for a shorter duration?
    • Assess factors like the local housing market, the rate of home price appreciation, and your own financial stability before making a decision.
  3. Can I really profit from a home if I don’t live in it for five years?
    • Yes, it’s possible, especially in markets with high appreciation rates. However, individual outcomes may vary.
  4. How can New Way Mortgage help me with my home buying decisions?
    • We provide personalized advice, considering your specific situation and goals to help you make informed choices.
  5. What’s the importance of flexibility in financial decisions?
    • Being flexible allows you to adapt to life’s changes and seize opportunities that may not align with rigid rules.

Want to talk to a friendly experienced team member?

📞 Talk or Text at 916-570-6979 or shoot us an 📧 hello@newwaymortgage.com

Rather schedule an appointment? No problem click 📆 to schedule a time that works for you 😎

Back To Top
Translate »